Big Brother 2007 voting controversy
Elizabeth July 31st, 2007
In what I hope will be my final Big Brother post, I want to draw attention to the huge mess made of the voting process during last night’s Finale. From everything I’ve read tonight (at Behind Big Brother, the Ten forums and various blogs) I am of the opinion that the $450,000 was quite possibly awarded to the wrong person.
I was first suspicious of technical issues when I was woken by an SMS at 1:22am, telling me that voting had ended (and therefore, that my vote hadn’t been counted). My very last vote was sent at 8:15, half an hour before the voting lines closed, so the error wasn’t mine. As replies are only sent once per day (rather than once per vote) I have no way of knowing which of my votes contributed to the final outcome, only that I was charged for them.
Only 500 votes separated Zach and Aleisha when the lines closed, and at one point there was a difference of only 64 votes. Considering how many angry people are blogging and commenting about this screw-up, it’s not much of a stretch to suggest that Zach could have been the true winner last night. This scenario is further supported by the fact that rabid Zach fans were frantically trying to help him catch up to Aleisha, once their identities were revealed on the graphs.
I left a comment on Ten’s forums myself, which I’ll re-post here for the sake of the search engines. I’m happy to add to the pressure being directed towards Big Brother producers on this issue.
I am just another dissatisfied voter and viewer who is waiting for an appropriate response from Channel 10, Southern Star Endemol and Legion about the technical issues that resulted during last night’s Big Brother Finale.
I sent save and evict votes well in advance of the advertised closing time, as listed below:
“Aleisha” to 19927283 at 7:03pm
“Aleisha” to 19927283 at 7:04pm
“Aleisha” to 19927283 at 7:36pm
“Aleisha” to 19927283 at 7:36pm
“Aleisha” to 19927283 at 8:13pm
“Aleisha” to 19927283 at 8:13pm
“Aleisha” to 19927283 at 8:13pm
“Aleisha” to 19927283 at 8:14pm
“Zach” to 19938428 at 8:14pm
“Zach” to 19938428 at 8:15pm
“Zach” to 19938428 at 8:15pm
“Zach” to 19938428 at 8:15pmAt 7:14pm, 10 minutes after my first two votes, I received the following SMS from Big Brother:
BB: Thanks for your vote! U won’t receive any further replies. For all the BB action and goss watch TEN weeknights at 7:00 or go 2 bigbrother.3mobile.com.au
It is interesting to note that my successful vote/s were sent before the graphs were revealed to viewers, complete with the names of the housemates that belonged to each value.
Thinking that everything was fine, I continued to send save and evict votes until 8:15pm, noting that the lines closed at 8:45pm. Although I was frustrated by the length of time taken to announce the winner, I accepted that recounting was necessary to ensure that the right person was evicted. I was satisfied that, if nothing else, at least my votes were being counted and would contribute meaningfully to the outcome.
At 1:22am this morning I received the following SMS from Big Brother:
BB: The voting period is now offline! For all the BB action and goss watch TEN weeknights at 7:00 or go 2 bigbrother.3mobile.com.au
I have no way of knowing which of my votes were counted, and which fell victim to the clogged lines. All I know for sure is that I have been charged for all of these votes, and that at least one of them (but realistically, probably several of them) did not contribute to the outcome of the Big Brother Finale.
Considering that only 500 votes separated the winner from the runner up, and that at one point during the show only 64 votes separated them, it is safe to say that the technical issues have potentially affected the outcome of Big Brother 2007. I believe that there is a strong possibility that $450,000 has been awarded to the wrong person.
I acknowledge that technical issues can happen, but I believe that they were completely preventable in the case of last night’s finale. I was disgusted at the blatant money-grabbing tactics of the producers in deciding to name the final 2 housemates on the voting graphs throughout the show, and believe that this decision altered the outcome significantly. If the number of complaints on this forum (and others) are anything to go by, the revenue raised by last-minute voters was astronomical and I have no faith that the money I spent resulted in meaningful votes.
I only hope that the extra revenue raised by greedy Big Brother producers compensates for the lack of faith that I now have in the integrity of the process.
And my response to another poster, shortly after:
fireit wrote: I think the underlying thing out of all of this is that it affected _everyone_. It’s not just one person’s evict / save votes were lost.
I understand your point, fireit, but I think your comment oversimplifies things. I don’t think we can ignore the impact that the graphs had on the type of votes received during those last couple of hours, as Zach fans tried to frantically catch him up to Aleisha.
For what it’s worth, I was voting to save Aleisha and evict Zach and therefore got the outcome that I wanted. However, I strongly suspect that Zach would have won the series had the votes been tallied correctly and that the $450,000 has been awarded to the wrong person.
If the possibility of this exists, I think we have a responsibility to apply pressure to those responsible and make sure that Zach receives an equal prize.
So there, that’s what I think. Considering the way that Big Brother producers have treated its viewers like complete idiots this year, I’m more than happy to make some noise about this.
On a lighter note…
If my site stats are anything to go by, the 2007 version of the Big Brother Turkey Slap is the “Chicken Slap”. Google is a beautiful thing.
boadie throwing the chicken at gretel
big brother final bodie throwing chicken
gretel big brother chicken
gretel bodie chicken
bodie gretel head rubber chicken
gretel bodie chicken slap
Bodie Big Brother chicken Gretel
Gretel Rubber Chicken







